Ice cream makes a sweet finish for birthdays, weddings, office celebrations, and family dinners. Think a sundae guests build themselves or a warm brownie with a melting scoop.
Choose one format, prepare a little ahead, and keep the ice cream frozen until serving.Palm leaf dessert plates and bowls add a welcoming touch—and leave you with fewer dishes to wash.
Which Ice Cream Flavors Should You Choose?
In Instacart's report on 2025 ice cream orders, vanilla led with about 21%, followed by chocolate (7.9%), cookie dough (6.9%), cookies & cream (5.8%), and chocolate fudge/brownie (5.1%). These familiar flavors are a useful starting point for your party menu.
The report also highlighted regional preferences: butter pecan in the South, coffee in New England, and Rocky Road in the West. Add a dairy-free fruit sorbet to give guests another option.
Here are four sweet ideas for your next gathering:
1. Build-Your-Own Sundae Bar
A little choice makes dessert more fun:
-
Flavors — vanilla, chocolate, and cookies & cream or salted caramel
-
Toppings — chocolate sauce, caramel, whipped cream, Oreo crumbles, and sprinkles
-
Serve — 4-inch palm leaf bowls with 4-inch wooden spoons, or deeper, round or square 5-inch bowls with 6-inch spoons
Perfect for birthdays or a relaxed backyard party.
2. Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches
A familiar treat with a playful twist:
-
Classic — chocolate chip cookies with vanilla or cookie dough ice cream
-
Something different — chocolate cookies with strawberry cheesecake, or pistachio cookies with pistachio ice cream
-
Serve — stack flat 4-inch or 6-inch party plates beside the serving area
Great for guests who enjoy a dessert they can pick up.
3. Warm Desserts à la Mode
Warm baking, cold ice cream, comforting flavors:
-
Classics — brownies with vanilla ice cream, or apple pie with butter pecan
-
More options — fruit cobbler, waffles with berries, or apple strudel
-
Serve — 6-inch or 8-inch palm plates, with a wooden fork and knife beside each plate.When choosing plates for catering, allow room for both the dessert and a scoop of ice cream.
Just right for a cozy dinner or fall celebration.
4. Affogato and Ice Cream Floats
A sweet finish in a cup:
-
Affogato — vanilla ice cream topped with freshly brewed espresso
-
Floats — vanilla ice cream with root beer, or strawberry ice cream with cream soda
-
Serve — 4-ounce disposable hot cups for mini affogatos or tasting portions, and 8- to 12-ounce cold cups for single-scoop floats. Add mini wooden spoons, or straws for floats
Lovely after dinner or during a casual party.
Set a Welcoming Dessert Table
Pair the natural grain of palm leaf plates with simple napkins, jars of toppings, and handwritten flavor labels. Keep disposable bowls, plates, and wooden utensils within easy reach.
Why These Ice Cream Ideas Work
-
Guests can choose flavors and toppings
-
Many components can be prepared ahead
-
Small portions make tasting easy
-
Compostable plates and bowls simplify cleanup
Ready to gather around something sweet?
